• Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Categories
    • Craft
    • Fashion + Beauty
    • Featured
    • Film + TV
    • Gadgetry
    • House + Home
    • Kids
    • Life Dorkage
    • Love + Sex
    • Opinion
You are here: Home / Film + TV / Why you shouldn’t watch The Walking Dead

Why you shouldn’t watch The Walking Dead

November 3, 2010 By Rob Hinchcliffe

The Walking Dead TV series

Next week the television adaptation of Robert Kirkman’s epic zombie comic series, The Walking Dead, hits our screens courtesy of FX (via AMC).

You probably knew that already. You’ve probably seen the huge billboard posters with Andrew ‘Egg’ Lincoln’s stubbly, resolute face staring out of them. You’ve probably read a broadsheet article about Frank ‘Shawshank Redemption’ Darabont’s involvement with the project, and you’ve probably watched the startlingly effective trailer on YouTube (see below) and revelled in its clever use of the Walker Brothers hit ‘The Sun Ain’t Gonna Shine Anymore’.

So if you know everything there is to know about the Walking Dead already, why am I writing this article? Well, I’m writing this to beg you not to watch it.

Experience the comic

Let me clarify: if you haven’t read The Walking Dead in comic form, then please, for all that is good and holy (or at least, undead and slightly mouldy), go and buy it now; hole up in a safe place with plenty of tinned food, and read it from cover to cover. Then, and only then, should you venture out into the world again to purchase the box set or watch the repeats.

Why am I saying this? Because I really, genuinely believe that if you watch the Walking Dead before you experience the comic, then you are denying yourself one of the most fantastic pop culture experiences of the past decade.

Think I’m exaggerating? Go and find someone who watched Zac Snyder’s Watchmen before they read the graphic novel. Ask them how that worked out, and remember to duck and make a note of the nearest exits as you do it.

Happily, I think The Walking Dead will make a much easier transformation to the screen than Watchmen did. Alan Moore’s superhero masterpiece was all but unfilmable (not that this stopped Snyder obviously), while Kirkman’s undead opus seems to have mirrored the ambition, scope and format of the ‘New Golden Age of Television’ (TM) that we’ve been lapping up for the past ten years, with a large cast of characters, unabashed violent imagery, unbridled swearing, and sheer unpredictability, all of which make it a cultural bedfellow of The Sopranos and Deadwood, as opposed to the blockbuster Hollywood comic adaptations like Spiderman and Batman.

Comic snob

I should emphasise here: I’m not being a comic snob. Honestly, I’m not. If I wanted to do that I could bang on about how waiting a whole month for the next issue to come out, and digesting the story over five long years is the only way to experience The Walking Dead. But that’s bollocks, so I won’t. And I won’t say that the comic is better than the TV series because it came first, or even because the comic medium is somehow inherently just ‘better’. Because that’s bollocks too.

What I will say is this: The Walking Dead is one of the finest comics I have ever read. And if the word ‘comic’ causes you problem, then let me rephrase… The Walking Dead is one of the finest stories I’ve ever read. It’s the only comic to make me physically gasp out loud as I turned the pages. I have never cared so much about comic characters as much as I have the ones Kirkman has so wonderfully created here; and the numerous narrative devices, plot twists, and heart-wrenching tension that arrive with each issue are so deftly delivered that you almost forget that there’s a zombie or two waiting to be decapitated just around the corner.

And I don’t care how carefully Darabont and co spin their celluloid, they’re never going to get close to the pure gold of the original material. And so why would you risk diluting that experience by watching the TV show first?

Go now. You have until Friday to track down at least the first trade paperback (although the Compendium Vol 1 is a very handsome volume, and a snip at £30). You won’t regret it, I promise.

Nick Bryan will be reviewing The Walking Dead for Dork Adore every week. The show starts on Friday 5th November on FX.

Rob Hinchcliffe

Rob's a 30-something Northerner who currently lives in Crystal Palace in South-East London. Rob started a blog called The Big Smoker that later became Londonist. He now works as a Community Strategist for TH_NK, a digital agency based in Newcastle and London.

More Posts - Website

Please share if you enjoyed this!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr

Related

Related Posts

  • Merlin - Goblin's Gold reviewMerlin: Goblin’s Gold – Dork Review
  • Game of Thrones: The Bear And The Maiden FairDaddy’s Home And He’s Brought A Bear… Game of Thrones S3E7 – Dork Review
  • Doctor Who: The Power Of ThreeDoctor Who: The Power Of Three – Dork Review
  • Hollywood GlitzStrictly Come Dancing Review – Week Two Vs. Hollywood Week

Filed Under: Film + TV, Opinion Tagged With: Comics, FX, The Walking Dead, TV, TV Reviews

Hey there, dork

You're a nerd, we're all nerds, let's make something beautiful happen. Sign up for our newsletter. We promise not to use your details inappropriately.

Yes, I need more email!

Comments

  1. Jess McCabe says

    November 3, 2010 at 10:32 am

    Too late – I watched the pilot without having read the comics :/

    In my defense, I *thought* I had read the comics, but had them confused with a different zombie apocalypse.

  2. Nick Bryan says

    November 3, 2010 at 2:37 pm

    I've read the first twelve issues of the comic, and enjoyed them a lot. Not sure I have the time to read the other sixty-something issues pre-air, sadly. Greatly looking forward to seeing how the TV show people adapt it. Also, I'm a huge Andrew Lincoln fan.

  3. Chris Cunningham says

    November 4, 2010 at 2:02 am

    I think you’ve called this one wrong. Watchmen was a feature-length adaptation of an entire comic. The Walking Dead, at least as far as I’m led to believe, stretches the entire first graphic novel out through six-and-a-half episodes. If anything, the first episode significantly expanded on several scenes up until now and hasn’t elided anything of note.

    I thought this would be good, but I was expecting to find Lincoln a little jarring as a Southerner (though I thought he was otherwise an ideal casting) and for it to fail to give off quite the same feel as the comic. I am beyond pleased that not only does Lincoln work perfectly as Rick but that those parts of the first episode which weren’t scene-for-scene perfect adaptations were significant improvements.

    If the rest of the season lives up to the first episode this will absolutely blaze trails.

    • Rob Hinchcliffe says

      November 5, 2010 at 2:34 pm

      Hey Chris – I think I misrepresented myself a little bit. I didn't want to say that Darabont and co won't make a good job of this, I just think that the comic is so well done, that it deserves reading before seeing the story in another medium.

      I think people might get more out of it if they're able to compare the tv series to the comic (which is what you've done, and it's obviously hitting the right buttons), rather than the other way around.

  4. Swineshead says

    November 5, 2010 at 2:06 am

    I read the comics first, so go me… but the first episode was a corker. Went in cynical, came out wanting hours and hours more.

  5. Dean says

    November 11, 2010 at 5:49 pm

    Of course, the flip side is, that if the TV show turns out to amazing, perhaps even, better than the comic, then by reading the comic you're spoiling the TV show for yourself. I'm torn on this one, I could go either way, will probably wait for the whole first season and see what the reviews are like

  6. simondoggett says

    November 16, 2010 at 3:33 pm

    Right.

    Now we're on episode 3 or so, and I've now caned my way through 78 issues of the comic, I'd like to chime in to say what utter cobblers this is Mr Hinchcliffe.

    What Darabont has done, with Kirkman helping him, is quite astonishing. The narrative differences between the two really help both versions compliment each other.

    So watch it.

  7. Sbbn says

    January 16, 2011 at 1:56 am

    Thanks for the advice, read to issue 80 over a couple of weeks the caught the repeats, and I'm very glad that that I did it that way around.

  8. Footiefan says

    March 7, 2011 at 11:16 pm

    I'm going to have to disagree with you.

    There's no way I would read a 'comic', Not read one for 20-30 years and even then it was 'Bunty' with the cut-out wardrobe on the back. Someone bought me a graphic novel type compendium thing that didn't do anything for me, so it didn't appeal.

    But…I always appreciate a good zombie flick so I managed (eventually) to watch the Walking Dead, loved every moment of it, kept seeing mention of the comic and eventually gave in. Changed my life! I want to read them all in a mammoth session but I'm pacing myself and enjoying every single second. Really appreciate setting it in the aftermath, parts are slightly reminiscent of Day of the Triffids (my favourite book), love the drawings and dreading the moment I catch up with present day.

  9. ANA THE BANANA says

    November 17, 2011 at 4:31 am

    YES READ THE COMICS FIRST, YESTERDAY I BOUGHT VOL. 2 AND 3 AND IT IS SOOOOOOO GOOD!! ALTHOUGH I STARTED WATCHING THE SHOW FIRST, I JUST HAD TO GET THE COMICS AS WELL. SAME STORY BUT IT’S ALSO VERYYYYYYYY DIFFERENT! I FINISHED THE COMICS IN LESS THAN 2 HOURS, IM UPSET, I NEED TO GET THE OTHER 11 VOLUMES SOON. HAHAHA.

  10. Dizzle says

    November 25, 2012 at 4:46 am

    Moldy*… duh

Trackbacks

  1. The Walking Dead: Days Gone Bye - Dork Adore review | Dork Adore says:
    November 7, 2010 at 11:41 am

    […] it again, rather than watching some rushed adaptation. Rob Hinchcliffe wrote an excellent post on why you should read the Walking Dead comics first, and I’m not indifferent to that view, but based on this pilot, the TV show might be an excellent […]

  2. The Walking Dead: Guts - Dork Adore Review | Dork Adore says:
    November 15, 2010 at 11:38 am

    […] More The Walking Dead on Dork Adore | Why you shouldn’t watch The Walking Dead […]

  3. The Walking Dead: TS-19 - Dork Adore Review | Dork Adore says:
    December 13, 2010 at 5:56 pm

    […] In short, a few wobbles, but I still enjoy the assembled actors, as well as the tone of it. Hopefully we’ll get back to the raw survival vibe in season two, rather than veering into more generic action. And if you need something to scratch your itch during the lengthy wait, why not take Rob Hinchcliffe’s suggestion and read the comics? […]

Welcome to the Dorkside!

About Us
We are a group of geeks with interests that range from crafting to the latest lifehacks. If you can be geeky about something, we're probably covering it! Here are some of our most popular current obsessions:

Doctor Who :: The Walking Dead :: Craft Patterns :: Fifty Shades of Grey :: Apple :: Game of Thrones :: TV Reviews

Recent Comments

  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Brittney muns on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Recent Posts

  • Edifier Prisma Bluetooth Speaker with ‘Storm-trooper’ styling
  • Gtech AirRam Mk2: Our new favourite battery-powered vacuum cleaner
  • These are my 10 Commandments for Email. What are yours?
  • Are you brave enough for a Personal Barber shaving box?
  • What parenting gadgets are actually worth getting?
  • Doctor Who LEGO is upon us! Get it before it sells out!

Most Popular Reads

  • Time Heist: Doctor Who does Ocean’s Eleven
  • This is only going to make my Netflix problem worse
  • Peppa Pig knitting and crochet patterns! Update: And Sewing!
  • Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Dork Adore

  • Advertising
  • Dork Adore Writers
  • Contact Dork Adore
  • Discount Codes
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Competition Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Writing for Dork Adore
  • Latest Posts

Categories

  • Craft
  • Fashion + Beauty
  • Featured
  • Film + TV
  • Gadgetry
  • House + Home
  • Kids
  • Life Dorkage
  • Love + Sex
  • Opinion

Follow Dork Adore On

RSS
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

Miramus Ltd © 2014 · All Rights Reserved