• Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Categories
    • Craft
    • Fashion + Beauty
    • Featured
    • Film + TV
    • Gadgetry
    • House + Home
    • Kids
    • Life Dorkage
    • Love + Sex
    • Opinion
You are here: Home / Film + TV / Doctor Who: A Christmas Carol – Dork Review

Doctor Who: A Christmas Carol – Dork Review

December 27, 2010 By Nick Bryan

Doctor Who: A Christmas CarolThe Doctor Who Christmas Special was even more important this year, as the rest of the festive schedule was looking particularly desolate. Christmas night itself was almost empty of worthwhile entertainment, so I too was relying on the Doctor to save Christmas in my own small way.

So did Matt Smith and Steven Moffat deliver? Or will we need to wait until next year? More importantly, what did my mum think?

More Christmassy Than An Explosion At Santa’s Workshop

Moffat had said in the pre-match interviews that he wanted to deliver the most festive possible special, in particular because last year’s “The Epic Death Scene Of David Tennant” was comparatively downbeat. And all the elements are certainly in place, although he leaves a larger sense of tragedy than I expected.

But there’s flying, snow, a sleigh, a clear acknowledgment of the source material and, most importantly, both fun and sentiment. I came away feeling cheered, although it was also fairly convoluted for Christmas night. I’m not sure I’d have followed it if I hadn’t been sober and refreshed by a mid-afternoon nap.

Someone Has Emptied The Ponds!

Notable by their absence were regular companions Amy and Rory. Akin to previous Christmas specials, the Doctor is accompanied by guest-star assistants Michael Gambon and Katherine Jenkins, which leaves the regulars shoved off to one side. Due to their lack of presence in the publicity, I suspected it would go this way, but I admit to still feeling disappointed.

I suppose this shows how well Moffat and Karen Gillan have endeared Amy Pond to the audience, and I imagine we’ll get all the sickening Amy/Rory action we want next year. I laughed at the explanation for their old-school costumes, which caused pre-episode speculation about time travel and such, but ended up being a tad less high-minded.

Mrs Bryan Reviews Who

Anyway, they definitely threw everything in this year. I enjoyed the level of imagination on display, but wasn’t totally sure how well it hung together. And my mother, having ignored the previous Matt Smith episodes, commented that it was all a bit strange and silly, and did they really need those fish as well as everything else?

So, perhaps a good episode for the fans, rather than the casual onlooker? How did your family take “A Christmas Carol”? Do you need to watch it again on iPlayer? And were you as excited as me about the trailer for series six?

More Doctor Who on Dork Adore | Doctor Who and Sherlock news a-go-go from Edinburgh

Nick Bryan

Nick learned to read and write at an early age. This has developed into an unhealthy need to either write stories or consume them for later dissection. He reviews film and TV on Dork Adore and The Digital Fix, lives in London and enjoys a nice white beer.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:
TwitterGoogle Plus

Please share if you enjoyed this!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr

Related

Related Posts

  • Atlantis: A Boy of No ConsequenceCan Atlantis even make a man jumping a bull boring? S1E3 – Dork Review
  • dalek_flowerpot_craftsterGerminate! Germinate! Dalek Plant Pot
  • Doctor Who: The Crimson HorrorThe North – More Aliens Than Mars? Doctor Who S7BE6 – Dork Review
  • Atlantis: White LiesSame dung, different week – something must change! Atlantis S1E5 – Dork Review

Filed Under: Film + TV Tagged With: BBC, Christmas, Doctor Who, Karen Gillan, Matt Smith, Michael Gambon, Steven Moffat, TV Reviews

Hey there, dork

You're a nerd, we're all nerds, let's make something beautiful happen. Sign up for our newsletter. We promise not to use your details inappropriately.

Yes, I need more email!

Comments

  1. Kat Arney says

    December 27, 2010 at 12:58 pm

    I half-watched it (while catching up on all the irritating admin I've been avoiding all year) and thought it was quite fun. La Jenkins may be able to sing but she can't really act, and Gambon was excellently hammy and suitably Scroogey. Good Christmassy fun, IMHO. But I'm not really a Who fan, despite the knitted Dalek…

    My parents also half-watched it (while mostly dozing in a port-fuelled haze) and we can conclude that after all these years, my Dad still has the hots for Haydn Gwynne while my mum is incapable of following a plot more complicated than Spot Goes Shopping.

    • Nick Bryan says

      January 2, 2011 at 2:48 pm

      The fact the maker of the knitted Dalek isn't a Doctor Who fan is quite upsetting to me. But yes, it was definitely fun. Which, on Christmas, is all they're really going for. Just a strange, twisty kind of fun.

  2. Katie says

    December 28, 2010 at 1:30 pm

    I haven't seen it yet. Can't wait to watch!

  3. fairyhedgehog says

    December 28, 2010 at 6:40 pm

    I think you're right. Three of us are avid Dr Who fans and we really enjoyed it. My husband is an occasional watcher and thought it was rather silly.

    I enjoyed the first half more than the second half but I thought it all tied up wonderfully.

  4. Katie says

    January 1, 2011 at 10:12 am

    I really enjoyed it! Finally watched it the other day and wasn't disappointed. Jenko couldn't act, but she looked nice and made some appropriately Christmassy noises, so it didn't matter.

    And some great lines — Moffat does know how to write a good gag.

    • Nick Bryan says

      January 2, 2011 at 2:47 pm

      She could've been worse, but yeah, it was an odd choice. They could've gotten a proper actress in and just dubbed Jenkins in, and I doubt anyone would've judged them.

Trackbacks

  1. Upstairs Downstairs, The Royle Family, Doctor Who TV Reviews | Dork Adore says:
    December 28, 2010 at 4:01 pm

    […] And check out Nick’s full review of Doctor Who A Christmas Carol. […]

  2. Doctor Who: A Good Man Goes To War - Dork Adore Review | Dork Adore says:
    June 5, 2011 at 12:24 pm

    […] bits. Seeing Roman Rory again was a nice touch, though the explanation was flimsy, even compared to the last time he swung that way, and of course it’s good to have him trying to “be […]

Welcome to the Dorkside!

About Us
We are a group of geeks with interests that range from crafting to the latest lifehacks. If you can be geeky about something, we're probably covering it! Here are some of our most popular current obsessions:

Doctor Who :: The Walking Dead :: Craft Patterns :: Fifty Shades of Grey :: Apple :: Game of Thrones :: TV Reviews

Recent Comments

  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Brittney muns on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Recent Posts

  • Edifier Prisma Bluetooth Speaker with ‘Storm-trooper’ styling
  • Gtech AirRam Mk2: Our new favourite battery-powered vacuum cleaner
  • These are my 10 Commandments for Email. What are yours?
  • Are you brave enough for a Personal Barber shaving box?
  • What parenting gadgets are actually worth getting?
  • Doctor Who LEGO is upon us! Get it before it sells out!

Most Popular Reads

  • Time Heist: Doctor Who does Ocean’s Eleven
  • This is only going to make my Netflix problem worse
  • Peppa Pig knitting and crochet patterns! Update: And Sewing!
  • Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Dork Adore

  • Advertising
  • Dork Adore Writers
  • Contact Dork Adore
  • Discount Codes
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Competition Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Writing for Dork Adore
  • Latest Posts

Categories

  • Craft
  • Fashion + Beauty
  • Featured
  • Film + TV
  • Gadgetry
  • House + Home
  • Kids
  • Life Dorkage
  • Love + Sex
  • Opinion

Follow Dork Adore On

RSS
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

Miramus Ltd © 2014 · All Rights Reserved