• Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Categories
    • Craft
    • Fashion + Beauty
    • Featured
    • Film + TV
    • Gadgetry
    • House + Home
    • Kids
    • Life Dorkage
    • Love + Sex
    • Opinion
You are here: Home / Featured / Sherlock – A Study In Pink: Dork Review

Sherlock – A Study In Pink: Dork Review

July 26, 2010 By Nick Bryan

Sherlock - Benedict Cumerbatch and Martin Freeman

After a long wait, Sherlock bounds onto BBC1 to solve mysteries and seem quirky. Although devoid of aliens or goblins, it has attracted the geek eye due largely to co-creators Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, both writers on the all-conquering Doctor Who.

The first episode, written by Moffat, has to introduce the modern day Holmes and Watson, then give them a case to show off with. Fortunately, it has a ninety minute slot, or this could have felt rather rushed. Pilot episodes are tricky beasts.

A jolly good show

From Doctor Who to Jekyll, even in Coupling, Moffat has structured stories to keep the audience guessing, withholding key information until the moment of greatest impact. So a detective story feels like a natural fit for him. This isn’t the most fiendish mystery, but a good introduction.

Our new Holmes is Benedict Cumberbatch, owner of the best name in acting. He looks younger than I imagine Holmes to be, but has thoughtful twitchiness off to a fine art. I also felt he resembled a baby-faced version of Matt Smith’s Doctor Who, but perhaps I had Who on the brain due to Moffat’s involvement.

There are a lot of visual flourishes, including text messages leaping up from mobile phones and scene transitions happening gradually across the screen. It gave it a strange comic book aesthetic, which looks cool to me right now. Whether it will age well, I do not know.

Holmes no longer a one-of-a-kind genius?

Of course, Moffat and chums are not the only ones homaging Conan Doyle in popular culture. There’s the Robert Downey Jr film franchise doing another cover version, not to mention House, featuring Hugh Laurie as the medical equivalent of Holmes.

Despite transplanting the action into 2010, Sherlock feels like the most traditional retelling, allowing Holmes to be a detective rather than action hero or angst-ridden drug addict. (Although the latter does get a moment.)

But all this referencing means the premise feels familiar. Since I’ve watched the afore-mentioned movie and over a hundred episodes of House, the combination of borderline-autistic deductive genius and exasperated yet affectionate companion doesn’t exactly seem fresh. Even the current Doctor Who isn’t a million miles from the Holmesian formula.

This isn’t really the fault of Sherlock, of course, and I’ll still be watching gleefully, because it’s a good, fun, well-made piece of television. But I personally would be  more blown away by it if not for those pesky other imitators.

More Sherlock on Dork Adore | Five things Moffat needs to build a better Holmes

Nick Bryan

Nick learned to read and write at an early age. This has developed into an unhealthy need to either write stories or consume them for later dissection. He reviews film and TV on Dork Adore and The Digital Fix, lives in London and enjoys a nice white beer.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:
TwitterGoogle Plus

Please share if you enjoyed this!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr

Related

Related Posts

  • Agents of SHIELD Season 2 promotional poster5 Highlights from Agents of SHIELD Season 2, Episode 1 – Shadows
  • Spooks: Series 10, Episode 6Spooks: Series 10, Episode 6 – Dork Review
  • Game of Thrones S2 Ep2: What is Dead May Never Die review
  • Dork Review: Doctor Who’s “Eleventh Hour”

Filed Under: Featured, Film + TV Tagged With: BBC, Doctor Who, House, Mark Gatiss, Sherlock, Steven Moffat, TV Reviews

Hey there, dork

You're a nerd, we're all nerds, let's make something beautiful happen. Sign up for our newsletter. We promise not to use your details inappropriately.

Yes, I need more email!

Comments

  1. TheLondoneer says

    July 27, 2010 at 8:28 pm

    I really enjoyed it – I don't know whether you noticed but they very consciously used 'Victorian' settings throughout – I'm just waiting for them to run down a cobbled street with gaslamps (no longer gas of course) somewhere off Brick Lane in the next episode – I had to resist the urge to clap 🙂

  2. rosieghoms says

    July 31, 2010 at 10:20 am

    well, start out by saying that I loved it and am looking forward immensely to the next episode …

  3. modular homes says

    August 25, 2010 at 6:58 am

    sherlock The BBC have just finished showing a new three part mini-series call “Sherlock” which … Episode 1: “A Study in Pink” The first episode in any series (even a mini-series) is basically

Trackbacks

  1. Mark Gatiss interview: “Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson are immortal” | Dork Adore says:
    July 27, 2010 at 8:02 am

    […] now, you’ll hopefully have read what our resident film and TV expert Nick had to say on the opening episode of Sherlock, and developed your own opinion on the modern adaptation. But how did Doctor Who power […]

  2. Sherlock - The Blind Banker: Dork Adore review | Dork Adore says:
    August 2, 2010 at 1:37 pm

    […] the first episode of Sherlock, audience reaction was hysterical. Twitter had an orgasm and reviewers spilled so much praise onto […]

  3. Sherlock – The Great Game: Dork Review | Dork Adore says:
    August 9, 2010 at 11:04 am

    […] short, intense affair of Sherlock came to an end on Sunday. After the first episode, we all threw an internet parade and someone at the Beeb announced excitedly that a new series was […]

  4. History of Horror, The Event and Psychoville TV reviews | Dork Adore says:
    November 2, 2010 at 12:31 pm

    […] whether as writer, performer or presenter is certainly one of them. From The League of Gentlemen to Sherlock, he’s been involved in some of the best telly of the 21st century, and — from what […]

  5. Dirk Gently, Natural World and The Apprentice TV Reviews | Dork Adore says:
    December 22, 2010 at 12:02 pm

    […] and pragmatic assistant who isn’t quite sure why he’s involved? So far, so Sherlock. Or Doctor Who. But hey, it’s a formula that’s worked in the past and it again works […]

Welcome to the Dorkside!

About Us
We are a group of geeks with interests that range from crafting to the latest lifehacks. If you can be geeky about something, we're probably covering it! Here are some of our most popular current obsessions:

Doctor Who :: The Walking Dead :: Craft Patterns :: Fifty Shades of Grey :: Apple :: Game of Thrones :: TV Reviews

Recent Comments

  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Lillian on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls
  • Brittney muns on Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Recent Posts

  • Gtech AirRam Mk2: Our new favourite battery-powered vacuum cleaner
  • These are my 10 Commandments for Email. What are yours?
  • Are you brave enough for a Personal Barber shaving box?
  • What parenting gadgets are actually worth getting?
  • Doctor Who LEGO is upon us! Get it before it sells out!
  • LEGO Scooby Doo Haunted Mansion review

Most Popular Reads

  • Time Heist: Doctor Who does Ocean’s Eleven
  • This is only going to make my Netflix problem worse
  • Peppa Pig knitting and crochet patterns! Update: And Sewing!
  • Here are 10 Things I Hate About the Gilmore Girls

Dork Adore

  • Advertising
  • Dork Adore Writers
  • Contact Dork Adore
  • Discount Codes
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Competition Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Writing for Dork Adore
  • Latest Posts

Categories

  • Craft
  • Fashion + Beauty
  • Featured
  • Film + TV
  • Gadgetry
  • House + Home
  • Kids
  • Life Dorkage
  • Love + Sex
  • Opinion

Follow Dork Adore On

RSS
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

Miramus Ltd © 2014 · All Rights Reserved